OUR STORY

McGarity’s Restaurant & Irish Pub® is owned and run by a husband-and-wife team who built one restaurant with one goal: every guest who walks through our doors should feel seen, welcomed, and well fed.

We call our style “Ireland meets the Ozarks.” Warm wood, Irish signs, music, and curtained booths bring the charm of a true Irish pub. Generous portions, genuine Ozark hospitality, and a strong local spirit bring the rest. Guests often tell us it feels like the place they wish they had back home.

McGarity’s is veteran owned. Our owner is a 30-year Naval Officer Veteran whose career took him around the world. In port after port, he was welcomed into the homes of local families and invited to share their table. Those meals became his favorite part of every journey, and he made a habit of asking for the recipes. Many came from grandmothers who had been cooking the same dishes for generations, the kind of recipes that never make it into a cookbook. That spirit of hospitality, and a good number of those lessons from home kitchens around the world, live on in our kitchen today. It is a big part of what makes McGarity’s truly one of a kind.

Those lessons come to life in a menu of Irish and American classics, each with a McGarity’s twist. Every meal is made fresh to order with high-quality ingredients, and we sweat the details most places never think about. Even our water, ice, and fountain sodas are filtered. Plates arrive with fine-dining presentation and flavor, without the fine-dining price, which is why so many couples make McGarity’s their date-night spot.

The same discipline and high standards that guided a 30-year Naval career run through our kitchen and our dining room every day. It is the kind of excellence you cannot learn in a classroom or pick up in a training course, and it has been noticed. McGarity’s was named Best Restaurant in Eureka Springs, Arkansas of 2026, featured on America’s Best Restaurants, named a Top 10 restaurant by NWA Travel Guide, and ranked the #1 Irish pub in Arkansas and #4 in the United States.

Our kitchen never closes early. Walk in one minute before closing time and we will still serve you anything on our menu, with full service. Whether you are a neighbor stopping in for a Guinness and shepherd’s pie or a traveler finding us for the first time, we would love to have you at our table. Sláinte!

OUR BRAND AND VISION STATEMENT

At McGarity’s Restaurant & Irish Pub®, taking care of people is the heart of what we do. We bring Irish warmth and Ozarks character together around the table, creating a restaurant where people can settle in, enjoy a satisfying meal, and feel welcome from the moment they arrive. We want every guest to feel that choosing to spend their time with us matters.

Our promise is to take pride in what we serve and responsibility for how we serve it. That means listening, paying attention to the details, and responding with care when something needs to be made right. We believe a restaurant earns its reputation through the everyday efforts of a team that cares about the people seated at its tables.

That responsibility extends to people in need. We provide freshly prepared meals completely free of charge, with no questions asked. We personally cover the cost, and every meal is served with the same care and dignity we would want for our own family.

Our vision is to make McGarity’s a lasting part of the Eureka Springs community: a restaurant our neighbors are proud to recommend, travelers remember long after returning home, and our team is proud to help build. As we grow, we want our reputation to reflect the things that matter most to us—food worth returning for, people who care, and a welcome that means something.

McGarity’s Restaurant & Irish Pub wood-paneled booth with Irish Pub sign and Featured On America’s Best Restaurants badge
Salted soft pretzels with beer cheese at McGarity’s Restaurant & Irish Pub

At McGarity’s, we believe great food starts with fresh, high-quality ingredients and a kitchen that takes pride in every plate. Every dish is cooked to order, our handcrafted cocktails feature house-made mixers, and our team is made up of some of the finest people you’ll ever meet.

We’re known for generous portions, genuine hospitality, and treating every guest who walks through our doors like they truly matter. Whether you’re visiting Eureka Springs for the first time or you’re one of the familiar faces we’re fortunate enough to see every week, we want McGarity’s to feel like a place you’re always welcome.

We believe a great restaurant should be about more than simply serving a meal. It should be a place where people can relax, laugh, celebrate, reconnect, and make memories around the table. We take pride in doing things the right way, from the ingredients we choose and the drinks we create to the way our guests are treated from the moment they arrive.

We also believe value still matters. That means serving food we’re proud to put our name on, portions that leave you satisfied, and an experience that makes you want to come back. We’re fortunate to have an incredibly hardworking team that genuinely cares about this restaurant, our guests, and the community we call home.

At the end of the day, we want every person who visits McGarity’s to leave happier than when they walked in. Great food, great drinks, generous portions, and genuine hospitality—that’s what we’re about.

And one thing is certain: no one leaves McGarity’s hungry—not on our watch.

Owner, McGarity’s Restaurant & Irish Pub®

Experience the Best

Six jumbo chimichurri-marinated shrimp served in a coupe glass with cocktail sauce and lemon wedges at McGarity’s Restaurant & Irish Pub.
McGarity’s Shepherd’s Pie with beef, lamb, carrots, corn, sweet peas, and green beans in house-made gravy, topped with house-made mashed potatoes and Parmigiano Reggiano.
McGarity’s Strawberry Salad pictured with optional grilled chicken, strawberries, romaine lettuce, cucumbers, bacon, avocado, fresh jalapeño, and feta cheese.
McGarity's pub features: dedicated vegan and vegetarian menu, Irish-inspired dishes and American classics, fresh high-quality ingredients, generous portions, and genuine hospitality.

Why People Love Us

Authentic flavors, generous portions, warm Irish hospitality, and a welcoming pub atmosphere that feels like a little piece of Ireland right here in Eureka Springs, Arkansas.

We accommodate many allergies and dietary needs such as alpha-gal syndrome whenever safely possible. Please inform your server before ordering. Shared equipment and fryer cross-contact may occur.