McGarity’s Restaurant · Eureka Springs, Arkansas
McGarity’s Restaurant Menus in Eureka Springs
Our menu brings together elevated Irish & American classics with a McGarity’s twist—from Fish & Chips and Shepherd’s Pie to seafood, burgers, pastas & signature sides. Enjoy generous portions, dedicated vegan & vegetarian selections and gluten-free pasta options. Pair your meal with a handcrafted cocktail, craft beer or a selection from our extensive wine list. Come see what everyone’s raving about.
Every dish is prepared fresh and cooked to order. Please be patient—it’s worth it.We offer free meals for those in need, no questions asked.
Main Menu
Fresh-cooked starters, seafood, American & Irish classics, sandwiches, salads and signature sides.
Enlarge menuStarters
fresh house-made pico de gallo, house-made ranch, fresh jalapeños, melted sharp & white cheddar cheese on top of sweet potato waffle fries. may substitute with seasoned fries. add chimichurri-seasoned grilled chicken $6.95
two fried spicy meat pies filled with seasoned beef
house-made dip with aged cheddar. two large soft bavarian pretzels with sea salt
3 house-made egg rolls stuffed with corned beef & sauerkraut. served with thousand island dressing on the side
lightly battered with salt & pepper. served with marinara & lemon wedges
six jumbo house-battered shrimp. served with sweet red chili sauce
white & yellow cheddar cheese, pan-roasted chicken, ranch, jalapeño & fresh house-made pico de gallo inside an x-large flour tortilla. side of sour cream
white cheddar. mild or spicy. choice of house-made ranch or marinara
six jumbo chimichurri-marinated shrimp served with house-made cocktail sauce
four quail medallions stuffed with mild jalapeño, wrapped in bacon & drizzled with house-made bourbon dijon
Seafood
guinness-battered cod, house-breaded shrimp, skin-on seasoned fries, house-made cocktail & tartar sauce. lemon wedges. london pub malt vinegar on the table
penne in house-made garlic sauce with jumbo grilled shrimp & parmigiano reggiano
blackened redfish topped with house-made garlic sauce & jumbo shrimp. lemon wedges. choice of 2 sides
jumbo shrimp resting on house-made spicy cajun creole red sauce served over house-made cheese grits
salmon topped with house-made creamy reduced white wine & dill sauce. lemon wedges. choice of 2 sides
two 5 oz hand-packed jumbo lump crab cakes, grilled & served with house-made cocktail sauce. choice of 2 sides
sashimi-grade ahi tuna crusted in sesame seeds & seared (raw in the middle). house-made wasabi & sweet & spicy plum sauce on the side. choice of 2 sides
Mac & Cheese
penne in house-made white cheddar sauce, topped with toasted breadcrumbs & parmigiano reggiano. add grilled chicken mixed in or house-battered fried chicken on top $6.95
Sandwiches
Sandwiches include skin-on seasoned fries, sweet potato waffle fries, or onion rings.
huge 10 oz steakhouse burger crafted from real, coarsely chopped steak. toasted brioche bun with lettuce, tomato, onion & pickles. choice of cheddar, provolone, swiss, pepper jack or blue cheese. add a patty $9.95. add bacon $2.95
tender corned beef, melted swiss cheese, grilled sauerkraut cooked in thousand island dressing. served on toasted marbled rye or toasted baguette. thousand island on the side
grilled or house-battered fried chicken served inside an x-large flour tortilla, brioche bun or toasted baguette. lettuce, tomato, avocado & house-made ranch
two irish bangers, sauerkraut, red onions, dijon mustard on a toasted buttered baguette
chicken salad with cranberries & pecans or yellowfin tuna salad. both on a baguette with lettuce & sliced tomato
Wild West Wings
non-breaded. carrots & celery sticks. flavors: buffalo, lemon pepper (dry rub), sweet & spicy bbq, sweet teriyaki, sweet red chili, mango habanero or sauce on the side. house-made ranch or blue cheese dressing. can be prepared normal or extra crispy
Herbivore
romaine lettuce, red onion, whole grape tomatoes, cucumber, avocado, fried onions, croutons, parmigiano reggiano & balsamic vinaigrette on the side
whole head of iceberg lettuce, whole grape tomatoes, red onion, crispy real bacon, avocado & blue cheese crumbles. blue cheese dressing on the side
loaded with strawberries, romaine lettuce, cucumbers, real bacon, avocado, fresh jalapeño & feta cheese served with balsamic vinaigrette on the side
salad add-ons: grilled chicken $6.95 · salmon $9.95 · seared ahi tuna $14.95 · jumbo shrimp $9.95. all salads come with dressing on the side
Carnivore
beef, lamb, carrots, corn, sweet peas, green beans in house-made gravy, topped with house-made mashed potatoes & parmigiano reggiano
beef, potatoes, carrots, peas, celery, guinness (reduced). served with toasted baguette
penne in house-made alfredo (parmigiano & romano). grilled chicken mixed in or house-battered fried chicken on top. finished with parmigiano reggiano
16 oz thick-cut bone-in grilled cured ham, mash, brown sugar & butter braised carrots, soft apple slices. sweet & spicy plum sauce on the side
2 large traditional irish sausages, mashed potatoes & grilled cabbage with bacon
corned beef & grilled cabbage served with mash. dijon mustard on the side
huge 16 oz hand-pressed cfs served with our signature house-made mashed potatoes & covered in our house-made white country gravy. good luck finishing it in one sitting
16 oz double-bone french-cut pork chop (butterflied), house-made mashed potatoes topped with house-made gravy & a side of carrots braised in brown sugar & butter
bowl of house-made spicy chicken & sausage gumbo served with toasted baguette
house-made mild or spicy chicken curry mixed with carrots, corn, green beans, peas & potatoes served over house-made cheese grits
À La Carte Signature Sides
traditional irish mash mixed with cabbage. $2.95 upcharge when chosen as an included side
make it loaded for $2.95
$2.95 upcharge when chosen as an included side
Gluten-Free Pasta
house-made garlic sauce tossed in gluten-free penne pasta & topped with jumbo grilled shrimp & parmigiano reggiano
house-made alfredo sauce with parmesan & romano cheese tossed with gluten-free penne pasta & grilled chicken breast
house-made cheese sauce tossed with cooked-to-order gluten-free penne pasta
Vegan & Vegetarian
cooked to order with thoughtful options for a range of dietary preferences
Enlarge menuVegan
two black bean patties served inside a toasted vegan brioche bun with vegan butter. romaine lettuce, tomato, pickled onions & pickles. served with choice of skin-on seasoned fries* or sweet potato waffle fries*
caramelized onions & organic jackfruit on a toasted baguette with vegan butter. vegan au jus on the side. skin-on seasoned fries* or sweet potato waffle fries*
vegan penne, garlic, carrots, corn, sweet green peas, green beans & whole cherry tomatoes tossed in a house-made vegan pesto sauce
bbq jackfruit, grilled cabbage & pickled onions on a bun. choice of skin-on seasoned fries* or sweet potato waffle fries*
Vegan
skin-on seasoned fries* with jackfruit, house-made curry sauce (mild or spicy), grilled cabbage & pickled onions
lettuce, cucumber, tomatoes, avocado & pickled onions with a black bean patty & vinaigrette
Vegetarian
garden vegetables & honey mustard in a flour tortilla. choice of skin-on seasoned fries*, onion rings* or sweet potato waffle fries*
mac & cheese with cajun jackfruit & breadcrumbs
Dietary & Allergy Notice
Items are identified as vegan or vegetarian based on their listed ingredients. *Fried items are prepared in shared fryer oil that is also used for non-vegan & non-vegetarian items. We are alpha-gal allergy-friendly & take dietary restrictions seriously. For many dietary needs, we use separate, disposable, one-time-use pans to reduce the risk of cross-contact. Our chef makes the final decision about whether a dish can be safely prepared for a specific allergy or dietary restriction.
Kids’ Menu
For children ages 12 & under only. Each 9.95 meal includes one entrée, one side & one kids’ cup drink.
Enlarge menuKids’ Entrées
Sides
Please ask your server for our current drink choices.
Free for children 5 & under* — includes one entrée, one side & one drink in a kids’ cup. Dine-in only.
Kids’ meal pickup: Kids’ meals are available through online ordering for 9.95 each. The complimentary meal for children 5 & under is available only when dining in.
Kids’ menu pricing is reserved for children only.
Please notify your server or any staff member of any & all food allergies.
Beer
domestic, imported, draft, craft, cider & low-calorie selections. alcohol by volume is listed where applicable
Enlarge menuDomestics · 4.95
Imports · 5.95
Draft Beer
Low-Calorie / Low-Carb Craft
Easy-drinking, flavorful light beer with a subtly sweet aroma. 99 calories and 5.2 carbs.
Crisp, light, and smooth Colorado lager. 105 calories and 5 carbs.
Easy-drinking, clean, crisp, and refreshing. 95 calories and 2.6 carbs.
Hoppy, crisp, and crushable with tropical aromas. 95 calories and 3.6 carbs.
Refreshing wheat beer brewed with real tangerine peel. 95 calories and 3.6 carbs.
Non-Alcoholic
Chocolate, coffee, and hazelnut notes.
Craft Beer, Cider & Seltzer
Dark malts, licorice root, and European lager yeast. 2025 gold medal winner.
Light-tasting cream ale brewed black.
Bready, cooked blueberry flavor in Flyway’s flagship wheat ale.
Brewed with natural Arkansas honey with a crisp finish.
Malty and easy-drinking with toffee, toasted oats, and hazelnut.
Medium-bodied with roasted caramel malt and cluster and cascade hops.
Rich, full-flavored deep amber beer with a smooth taste.
Strawberry, blackberry, and raspberry blend.
Sweet red apple flavor with a clean finish.
Strong Citra hops with a honey-malt finish.
Citrus, tropical fruit, and pine notes.
Crisp pineapple, mango, and pine notes.
Sweet malt with a hoppy finish and pine, citrus, and tropical fruit.
Generously hopped with mango, tangerine, and pineapple.
Hoppy with a balanced, slightly malty caramel finish.
Full-bodied roasted barley with fruity notes and a lush chocolate finish.
Full-bodied with dark chocolate, coffee, and caramel.
German pilsner malt and local wildflower honey.
Light malt base with hints of breadiness.
Belgian witbier brewed with orange peel and coriander.
Dark chocolate, light roast, and earthy notes.
Fruity aromatics, grapefruit hops, and a dry peppery finish.
Ask your server which flavors are available.
Mixology
classic cocktails, premium martinis & mcgarity’s house specialties
Enlarge menuPlease note: liquor and mixed drinks are subject to a 36.375% combined state, county, and city tax set by local and state authorities. Beer and wine are taxed at the standard sales-tax rate.
Premium Martinis
Tito’s vodka, triple sec, lemon juice, and simple syrup with a sugar rim. Other flavors available.
Tullamore D.E.W. Irish whiskey, apple schnapps, and cranberry juice.
Tito’s vodka and chocolate liqueur, topped with whipped cream.
Tito’s vodka, peach schnapps, cranberry, and orange juice.
Tito’s vodka, Baileys Irish Cream, and freshly ground espresso.
House Specialties · Made with Premium Liquor
Guinness, Baileys Irish Cream, and a Jameson shooter.
Hendrick’s gin, muddled cucumbers, fresh lime juice, and soda water.
Empress 1908 gin, triple sec, simple syrup, lemon juice, mint, and a sugar rim.
Código 1530 tequila, Grand Marnier, cranberry juice, lime juice, and a cranberry-sugar rim.
Jameson, elderflower liqueur, lemon juice, and cucumber.
Malibu coconut rum, melon liqueur, pineapple, and cream.
Premium House Cocktails
Jameson whiskey, peach liqueur, ginger ale, and orange juice.
Hendrick’s gin, simple syrup, and lemon juice topped with champagne.
Tito’s vodka, Hendrick’s gin, Bacardi rum, peach schnapps, triple sec, blue curaçao, and Red Bull.
Patrón tequila, triple sec, and house-made mix. Ask your server about other flavors.
Bacardi rum, pineapple juice, and muddled jalapeño.
Jameson, lime juice, and ginger beer.
Tito’s vodka and signature house-made spice mix.
Jameson whiskey, peach schnapps, blue curaçao, pineapple juice, and Sprite.
Jameson whiskey, freshly brewed coffee, and cream.
Bacardi rum, Malibu Original, melon liqueur, blue curaçao, pineapple juice, and Sprite.
Bulleit bourbon, bitters, orange, sugar, and Woodford Reserve bourbon cherries.
Anything on this menu can also be made with well liquor for a lower price.
Wine
glass & bottle prices are shown where available
Enlarge menuPinot Grigio
Light, refreshing citrus and green-apple flavors.
Citrus, ripe white peach, juicy pear, and tropical fruit.
Pale pink and elegant with peach, melon, and blackberry.
Chardonnay
Fragrant white peach, vibrant citrus, and a creamy texture.
Pineapple, mango, and papaya with vanilla and honey aromas.
Meyer lemon, Asian pear, and white flowers.
Stone fruit and baked lemon with a vanilla finish.
Sauvignon Blanc
Crisp lime zest and honeysuckle.
Tropical flavors and citrus with a crisp finish.
Bright melon, peach, and tropical-fruit notes.
Sparkling & Champagne
Apple and pear with toasty yeast and floral nuances.
Crisp, fragrant apple, peach, and pear.
White flower, honey, green apple, and toast.
Rosé, Moscato & Riesling
Fresh red fruit with mineral and floral notes.
Honey and peach aromas layered with tropical notes.
Crisp apple and white peach with subtle mineral notes.
Merlot
Rich fruit, chocolate, floral, and spice notes.
Ripe cherries and plums with a velvety finish.
Dark berry, creamy mocha, bittersweet chocolate, and silky tannins.
Blackberry, raspberry, and cassis with cedar, dark chocolate, and soft tannins.
Zinfandel, Sangria & Red Blends
Light, sweet red sangria with orange, lemon, and lime.
Full-bodied red currant, blackberry, and blueberry.
Sweet oak, toasty vanilla, dark fruit, and bourbon spice; aged three months in bourbon barrels.
Black cherry, cocoa, rosemary, and a velvety mouthfeel.
Pepper, cherry, sweet anise, and cinnamon.
Pinot Noir
Strawberry and raspberry with caramel, vanilla, and baking-spice barrel notes.
Baked rhubarb, wild strawberry, pie cherry, and toasted cocoa.
Floral, mineral, and cherry notes.
Malbec
Blackberry, white pepper, and chocolate.
Ripe plums, cherries, spice, and a hint of oak-aged tobacco.
Cabernet Sauvignon
Blackberry, toasted hazelnut, cinnamon, vanilla, and toasted oak.
Red and black fruit, spice, vanilla, and chocolate.
Blackberry, spice, ripe plum, vanilla oak, cola, and a robust finish.
Ripe black fruit, vanilla, spice, and a velvety finish.
Strawberry, cherry, raspberry, mint, basil, and pepper.
Complex black fruit, coffee, and a velvety finish.
Black stone fruit, clove, dried herbs, and soft structured tannins.
Chianti Classico Riserva
Red fruit and floral aromas with elegant tannins and a balanced finish.
Cherry, strawberry, light earth, and moderate length.
Desserts
all shareable desserts are 11.95
Enlarge menuspiced dessert featuring shredded carrots, pineapple, raisins & nuts
chocolate cake, yellow cake, cheesecake, strawberry fruit filling & chocolate mousse
light, fluffy & refreshingly tangy with cold lemon cream filling
artisan-quality, luxurious, indulgent treat with a deep chocolate profile
espresso-soaked chocolate layers, hazelnut mousse & honey ganache
Non-Alcoholic Drinks
fountain drinks, tea, coffee & bottled water
Enlarge menuFountain Drinks
unlimited refills
Glass-Bottled Water
Freshly Ground Whole-Bean Coffee
unlimited refills. decaf available
Hot Tea
all ice, water & fountain drinks run through a 3m water filtration system