Places to Eat in Eureka Springs: Fresh-Cooked Favorites at McGarity’s
Searching for places to eat in Eureka Springs usually means balancing several priorities: a menu with real variety, food prepared with care, a convenient location, and a dining room where everyone in the group can feel comfortable. McGarity’s Restaurant & Irish Pub brings those pieces together at 2070 E. Van Buren on Route 62 East, serving locals and visitors from one independently owned Eureka Springs restaurant.
A Restaurant-First Menu for Different Tastes
McGarity’s is built around the meal. The kitchen serves American and Irish-inspired favorites alongside seafood, burgers, steaks, sandwiches, salads, vegetarian dishes, vegan options, appetizers, and a dedicated children’s menu. That breadth makes the restaurant especially useful when one table includes guests with very different appetites.
Guests looking for comfort food can choose dishes such as Shepherd’s Pie, Bangers & Mash, Chicken-Fried Steak, or a stacked Reuben. Seafood choices include Guinness Fish, Shrimp & Chips, Garlic Shrimp Pasta, White Wine Salmon, Blackened Red Fish, Shrimp Creole & Grits, and grilled real-crab cakes. Burgers, fresh salads, sandwiches, pork chops, and lighter selections round out a menu designed for a complete lunch or dinner.
Fresh Preparation and Generous Portions
Every dish is cooked to order with fresh, high-quality ingredients. McGarity’s is not a fast-food stop, and the kitchen gives each plate the preparation time it needs. Portions are intentionally generous, so guests can settle in and enjoy a satisfying restaurant experience rather than a rushed meal.
House-made sauces, dressings, mashed potatoes, cheese grits, and other components help distinguish the menu. Fried items are cooked in a soybean and canola oil blend; other dishes are prepared without seed oils. Guests with allergies or dietary restrictions should speak with their server before ordering because shared equipment, preparation areas, and fryers create a risk of cross-contact.
An Easy Stop While Exploring Eureka Springs
McGarity’s Route 62 East location is convenient for travelers arriving in town, returning from an Ozarks outing, or planning an evening around Eureka Springs. The restaurant has on-site parking, accepts walk-ins, offers reservations for parties of one to six, and provides an online waitlist when guests want to check timing before arriving.
A full kitchen stays open until the restaurant closes. Hours are Monday through Thursday from 4:00 PM to 10:00 PM, Friday and Saturday from 11:00 AM to 11:00 PM, and Sunday from 11:00 AM to 10:00 PM. Parties of seven or more should call 479-363-6038 during business hours for assistance.
Plan Your Meal Before You Arrive
View the current menu at https://mcgaritysrestaurant.com/menu and browse restaurant and food photos at https://mcgaritysrestaurant.com/photo-album. Seafood diners can also read the fresh-cooked seafood guide at https://mcgaritysrestaurant.com/blog/2026/8/7/seafood-in-eureka-springs-a-fresh-cooked-dining-guide.
For parties of one to six, reserve online at https://tables.toasttab.com/restaurants/d5be2afc-5b09-4229-b74f-9d466fa835a8/findTime. To order pickup, visit https://order.mcgaritysrestaurant.com. Walk-ins are welcome, and guests can join the current waitlist at https://tables.toasttab.com/restaurants/d5be2afc-5b09-4229-b74f-9d466fa835a8/joinWaitlist.
Why McGarity’s Belongs on a Eureka Springs Dining List
Among the many places to eat in Eureka Springs, McGarity’s stands out by focusing on fresh cooking, broad menu choice, generous portions, and attentive hospitality. It is a full-service restaurant where seafood lovers, comfort-food fans, vegetarians, families, and hungry travelers can find a satisfying meal at the same table.
Whether the occasion is a relaxed dinner, a weekend lunch, takeout for the family, or a memorable meal during an Ozarks visit, McGarity’s is ready to welcome you.