Dinner in Eureka Springs: Cooked-to-Order Favorites at McGarity’s
When dinner in Eureka Springs calls for a substantial, freshly prepared meal, McGarity’s Restaurant & Irish Pub offers a restaurant-first experience with broad menu variety and generous portions. The locally owned restaurant at 2070 E. Van Buren serves American and Irish-inspired favorites, seafood, steaks, burgers, salads, sandwiches, vegetarian choices, and vegan options from one full kitchen.
Cooked-to-Order Dinner, Not Fast Food
McGarity’s prepares dishes fresh and cooks every order individually. That approach gives grilled, seared, baked, and breaded entrées the attention they need and allows house-made sauces, mashed potatoes, cheese grits, dressings, and sides to play a real part in the meal. Guests should plan for a relaxed dinner rather than expect a fast-food pace.
Portions are designed to satisfy. Whether the table orders comfort food, seafood, vegetables, or a mix of favorites to share, the goal is for every guest to leave well fed and cared for.
Hearty Entrées for a Big Appetite
Dinner guests looking for a hearty plate can consider the large Chicken-Fried Steak, a double-bone pork chop, Shepherd’s Pie, Bangers & Mash, steaks, or a stacked Reuben. McGarity’s burgers and sandwiches provide familiar choices, while house-made mashed potatoes, seasonal vegetables, seasoned fries, and other sides let guests build a complete meal.
The menu also includes appetizers for sharing, such as Irish Reuben Egg Rolls, wings, onion rings, pretzels with Irish pub cheese, shrimp cocktail, and other table-friendly starters. These dishes make it easy to begin a dinner with something everyone can sample.
Seafood for Dinner in Eureka Springs
Seafood is a major part of the dinner menu. Choices include White Wine Salmon with a house-made creamy reduced white wine and dill sauce, Blackened Red Fish with house-made garlic shrimp sauce, Sesame-Crusted Ahi Tuna, Garlic Shrimp Pasta, Shrimp Creole & Grits, Guinness Fish, Shrimp & Chips, and McGarity’s grilled real-crab cakes.
The crab cakes are $39.95 and arrive as two grilled cakes made with real crab meat, house-made cocktail sauce, and a choice of two sides. Read the complete seafood guide at https://mcgaritysrestaurant.com/blog/2026/8/7/seafood-in-eureka-springs-a-fresh-cooked-dining-guide.
Dinner Choices for Mixed Groups
Not everyone at the table has to want the same cuisine. The main menu combines comfort food, seafood, steaks, burgers, salads, and sandwiches, while a separate vegetarian and vegan menu includes substantial meat-free choices. A dedicated children’s menu helps families order a complete dinner without limiting adults to kid-focused food.
Guests with allergies or dietary restrictions should tell their server before ordering. The kitchen can discuss ingredients and possible accommodations, but shared equipment, preparation areas, and fryers create a risk of cross-contact. No dish can be guaranteed allergen-free, and the chef makes the final decision about safe preparation.
Plan Your Eureka Springs Dinner
McGarity’s is open Monday through Thursday from 4:00 PM to 10:00 PM, Friday and Saturday from 11:00 AM to 11:00 PM, and Sunday from 11:00 AM to 10:00 PM. The complete kitchen remains open until closing.
View the current menu at https://mcgaritysrestaurant.com/menu. For a broader look at the restaurant, read https://mcgaritysrestaurant.com/blog/places-to-eat-in-eureka-springs. Parties of one to six can reserve at https://tables.toasttab.com/restaurants/d5be2afc-5b09-4229-b74f-9d466fa835a8/findTime. Walk-ins are welcome, and pickup orders are available at https://order.mcgaritysrestaurant.com.
For parties of seven or more, call 479-363-6038 during business hours. If your search for dinner in Eureka Springs includes fresh cooking, generous portions, menu variety, and genuine hospitality, McGarity’s is ready for your table.