
Some dinners deserve more than a quick bite. Whether you’re celebrating an anniversary, a birthday, an engagement or a promotion, McGarity’s Restaurant & Irish Pub gives your special occasion the setting it deserves. We were named Best Restaurant in Eureka Springs, Arkansas of 2026 by Evergreen Awards, featured on America’s Best Restaurants and named a Top 10 restaurant by NWA Travel Guide. We’re also ranked the #1 Irish pub in Arkansas and #4 in the United States.
Fine-dining plates and ambiance, curtained booths and generous Irish portions make McGarity’s a natural choice for an anniversary dinner in Eureka Springs.
Why Celebrate at McGarity’s
We’re a veteran-owned, husband-and-wife-run restaurant at 2070 E. Van Buren, and every dish is prepared fresh and cooked to order. Our team takes care of you at the table so you can focus on each other, whether it’s your first anniversary or your fiftieth.
A Setting That Feels Like an Occasion
Warm wood, stained glass and Irish details set the tone the moment you walk in. Curtained booths give you a little privacy for a toast or a proposal, and our corner table, with its gilded high-back chairs and ornate mirror, turns any dinner into an event.
Ask for a booth in the notes when you reserve online. A seating preference is a request, not a guarantee of a particular booth or table. There’s no dress code: come in your favorite jeans or a suit for the occasion, and you’ll fit right in.
Build a Celebration Dinner
Start with something to share
- Quail Medallions stuffed with mild jalapeño, wrapped in bacon & drizzled with house-made bourbon dijon
- The Shrimp Cocktail: six jumbo chimichurri-marinated shrimp & house-made cocktail sauce
- Irish Cheddar Pub Cheese with two large soft Bavarian pretzels
Choose your entrées
- McGarity’s Crab Cakes: two 5 oz hand-packed jumbo lump crab cakes, grilled
- Sesame-Crusted Ahi Tuna, seared rare, with house-made wasabi & sweet & spicy plum sauce
- Blackened Redfish topped with house-made garlic sauce & jumbo shrimp
- The Pork Chop: a 16 oz double-bone, French-cut chop
- Irish Gammon (Ham) Steak: a 16 oz thick-cut, bone-in grilled cured ham
Finish with dessert for two
Every dessert is made to share. Choose the 5-Layer Chocolate Seduction Cake, the Chocolate Hazelnut Espresso Cake or the 5-Layer Atomic Cheesecake/Cake Blend, and add a cappuccino or espresso.
Browse the current menu before you visit.
Raise a Toast
Mark the moment with something sparkling: Bollicini Prosecco, J. Rogét Brut or a bottle of Gérard Bertrand Héritage An 825 Crémant de Limoux. Prefer a cocktail? Try a French 75 or an Espresso Martini. For red wine lovers, our bottle list includes Castello di Querceto Chianti Classico Riserva, Rutherford Hill Merlot and Quilt. Not drinking? Ask about Guinness 0.0 and our other non-alcoholic choices.
How to Reserve Your Special Occasion Dinner
- Reserve your table online for 1–6 guests at least 2 hours ahead.
- Mention the occasion and any booth request in your reservation notes.
- Arrive within 10 minutes of your reservation time, or your table goes to the next party.
- For parties of seven or more, call 479-363-6038 during business hours so our team can confirm availability and arrangements.
Planning a wedding rehearsal dinner or a catered celebration? Email info@mcgaritysrestaurant.com with your date, guest count and details, and our team will discuss availability and options.
Our kitchen serves until 10 p.m. Monday through Thursday and Sunday, and until 11 p.m. Friday and Saturday, so a late celebration is never a problem.
Celebrating Someone Who Can’t Join You?
A McGarity’s gift card makes an easy anniversary, birthday or thank-you gift. Buy one online and send it in minutes.
Special Occasion Questions
Is McGarity’s a fine-dining restaurant?
We’re an award-winning Irish & American restaurant with fine-dining plates and ambiance and a relaxed, come-as-you-are feel. You get elevated presentation and generous portions without a formal dress code.
Can we request a booth for our anniversary?
Yes. Mention it in the notes when you reserve online. A seating preference is a request, not a guarantee of a particular booth or table.
Do you host wedding rehearsal dinners?
Yes. Email info@mcgaritysrestaurant.com with your plans so our team can review the details and discuss availability.
Is there a dress code?
No. Whether you’re in shorts and a T-shirt or a suit for the occasion, you’ll fit right in.
Celebrate With Us
From a first-date anniversary to a milestone birthday, we would be honored to be part of your celebration. Reserve your table, tell us what you’re celebrating and come hungry. We’ll take care of the rest. Planning a regular night out? See our guide to a romantic date night in Eureka Springs.