Why McGarity’s Is One of the Best Restaurants in Eureka Springs
At McGarity’s Restaurant & Irish Pub, we believe a great meal starts with food cooked to order, generous portions, and a warm welcome. Add Irish pub character, American comfort food, and strong guest reviews, and you have the reasons we are proud to call McGarity’s one of the best restaurants in Eureka Springs.
We are a locally owned, kid-friendly Irish & American restaurant run by a husband-and-wife team. Our owner is a 30-year Naval Officer Veteran. That background in service shapes how we care for our guests and our community. Our only location is on Route 62 East, where Ireland meets the Ozarks and there is room at the table for families, couples, friends, and neighbors.
Why Guest Reviews Put Us Among the Best Restaurants in Eureka Springs
We have plenty to be proud of, and our guests help tell the story. As of September 9, 2026, McGarity’s held these ratings on three review platforms:
Review platform | Guest rating | Reviews |
|---|---|---|
4.8 out of 5 | 1,759 | |
4.8 out of 5 | 45 | |
4.7 out of 5 | 119 |
Those scores support our reputation as a top-rated restaurant and one of the best restaurants in Eureka Springs. They give first-time guests real feedback to explore before choosing where to eat. Follow the platform links to read the reviews and check the latest totals.
These are separate platform counts, so some guests may have reviewed us in more than one place. The figures are a dated snapshot of guest feedback. We are grateful for every guest who takes the time to share an experience, and we work to earn that trust with each meal we serve.
Irish Favorites and American Comfort Food, Cooked to Order
For us, being one of the best restaurants in Eureka Springs starts in the kitchen. We cook meals to order and serve generous portions. Our menu brings Irish pub favorites and American classics together, so friends with different tastes can enjoy a meal at the same table.
Start With a Taste of Ireland
Our shepherd’s pie is a hearty choice for a hungry evening. Fish and chips bring a classic pub meal to the Ozarks, while Irish Reuben egg rolls offer a fun way to start. If a pint is part of your plan, enjoy Guinness poured through our imported Irish draft system. The food, the setting, and the pour all help make a visit feel like a trip to the pub.
Find Your American Favorites
We’re home to the biggest chicken-fried steak in the Ozarks, served with house-made mashed potatoes and white country gravy.
Our most popular dishes include Blackened Redfish, Chicken Fried Steak, Shepherd’s Pie, Fish and Chips, Shrimp Creole, our pasta dishes, and Chicken & Sausage Gumbo. Seafood is a regular part of our menu, alongside burgers, vegetarian and vegan choices.
A great meal deserves a great drink. Explore our huge craft beer and wine list with amazing signature cocktails, and choose from a large, thoughtfully crafted vegan and vegetarian menu alongside our Irish and American favorites. Browse our full restaurant menu to find your next favorite dish.
A Warm, Kid-Friendly Place to Share a Meal
The setting is part of the pleasure. Warm, rich wood accents give McGarity’s its inviting Irish pub character, while booths with curtains add a romantic touch for couples. Excellent tableside service and generous portions make it easy to settle in for a family dinner, catch up with friends, or enjoy a night with your favorite person. Planning an evening for two? Explore our Eureka Springs date-night guide.
Families have their own reasons to stop in. Our kids menu is for children ages 12 and under. Children age 5 and under receive one complimentary kids meal when dining in with their family. That offer applies to dine-in meals only. We want a night out to be something the whole family can enjoy.
Fresh preparation takes time, and we think a meal is worth doing well. Come ready to settle in, share a starter, and enjoy the pub setting while we prepare your food.
Featured on America’s Best Restaurants, Rooted in Our Community
McGarity’s has been featured on America’s Best Restaurants. We are proud to share that look inside our restaurant with guests who have yet to visit. It is another way to get to know the food, the people, and the place behind the name.
NWA Travel Guide also named McGarity’s Restaurant & Irish Pub among its Top 10 Best Eureka Springs Restaurants. We are proud to see our Irish & American restaurant recognized alongside other local favorites.
Our community mission matters just as much to us. We offer free, freshly prepared meals to people who are genuinely in need, served with dignity and no questions asked. Food brings people together, and we believe a local restaurant should care for the people around it.
That is part of what being one of the best restaurants in Eureka Springs means to us: serving our neighbors as well as visitors. You can read more about our food and community on the McGarity’s blog.
Plan Your Visit to McGarity’s
Find our only location at 2070 E. Van Buren, Route 62 East, Eureka Springs, Arkansas. We serve dinner daily and lunch on Friday, Saturday, and Sunday. We welcome reservations and walk-ins, and pickup is available when you want to enjoy your meal elsewhere.
Reserve online for parties of one to six through our website. For seven or more, call (479) 363-6038. Check current hours before you head out, and use our digital waitlist when it is available during busy times.
Questions Guests Ask Before Visiting
Why Do We Call McGarity’s One of the Best Restaurants in Eureka Springs?
Our case rests on dated guest ratings, food cooked to order, generous portions, and a welcoming Irish & American restaurant experience. The table above gives you the review evidence to explore, and a visit lets you decide for yourself.
Are There Vegetarian and Vegan Choices?
Yes. Our large, thoughtfully crafted vegan and vegetarian menu gives guests plenty to explore alongside our Irish and American favorites. Check the current menu, and tell our team about any food allergies before ordering. We work in a shared kitchen and cannot guarantee zero cross-contact.
Can We Bring the Kids or Order Pickup?
Yes to both. We welcome families and offer a kids menu. Pickup is also available through our website; the complimentary meal for children age 5 and under is a dine-in offer.
If your search for the best restaurants in Eureka Springs has brought you to McGarity’s, we would love to welcome you. Come for a favorite dish or try something new, raise a glass, and make yourself at home. Sláinte!